1. GM Gifted Tokens
Keep a stack of small tokens on hand, and give them to players to show that you notice and appreciate their efforts to stay in character. Gifting a token draws everyone’s attention to a good bit of roleplay, and players can use it for a bonus later in the game when they need a small boost.
A reroll of a die, +2 to a roll, or an additional success are all good examples of what that reward could be, depending on the system you’re using.
2. Player Gifted Tokens
Similar to the first idea, you can set up a system where the players reward each other for good roleplaying. With so many things to keep track of while running a game, delegating the bonus system to the players can help ensure it actually gets used.
Because you have less control over how frequently and evenly these tokens are handed out, it’s a good idea to keep the bonus they give small.
3. Define Character Behaviors
Borrowing from Mouse Guard, you can encourage your players to define habits that help bring life to their characters during the game. My friend’s character, for example, would stop to light some pipeweed whenever he needed to solve a vexing problem.
At the end of a session you can reward players that used these behaviors to add to the scene. A typical reward for this would be bonus experience, or your system’s equivalent.
4. Poll Players After a Session
Sometimes players don’t put effort into their characters because they don’t feel invested in the campaign. It can be beneficial to step back and recalibrate a few days after a session by getting feedback from your players. Find out what they enjoyed and what directions they’re interested in exploring further. This will help everyone feel like they are contributing to a story, and not just trying to defeat the GM challenges.
Getting player buy-in to the story will encourage them to metagame in positive ways that add to the drama. Your players will come to the table with interesting ideas for advancing the story, and you can avoid preparing plot hooks that the group would ignore.
5. Create PC Side Plots
This requires a bit more planning on the part of both the players and the GM. Work with your players to add side plots for your campaign based on their desired character arcs. Balancing play between the character in focus and the rest of the party does take care, but the payoff for this effort can be some of your group’s best roleplaying.
This will be especially effective if the character arc resolutions, good and bad, have a measurable impact on the campaign’s end game. Everyone loves the buildup of friends and allies from all across the campaign, returning to aid the heroes when it comes time to storm the villain’s castle.
6. Write Scenes Between Sessions
Not all roleplayers are natural actors. In fact, a good number of people I’ve gamed with over the years have been more comfortable writing fiction than acting it out. One way that you might help these players to get in their comfort zone is through writing exercises between games. Start a scene focused on the PC, with the player and GM taking turns writing. I call these “.5 sessions,” and they can be used to explore character backgrounds, interact with NPCs in more depth, or anything else that might make a good scene for a single PC. As a bonus, you may find your players have a better handle on their characters at the gaming table as well.
While you should offer this option to all of your players, don’t try to require it. After all, the players that are already comfortable acting may find writing to be a struggle that they don’t enjoy. This exercise should be viewed as its own reward for those who are interested.
Of course, there is no one right way to encouraged your players to game in character. It may just be that the group needs to take a five minute break every hour to help everyone stay focused. Try a few different options and see what works for you. Once your group hits on something you all like, stay consistent and it will become easier to stay in character with each game.
Treat your friends to an evening of dark ritual murder. In a fictional game scenario, of course. Uncover your lost memories and save the day in our stand-alone game, The Voyage.