Commentary

Five Retaliatory Plot Points to Expect in Episode IX

Luke, Rey, and Kylo from The Last Jedi
It’s no secret that The Last Jedi diverges significantly from its predecessor, The Force Awakens. Whether this is the death of the Star Wars franchise or the greatest event in the history of science fiction depends on who you talk to, but it’s clear that Rian Johnson has upset the groundwork laid down by JJ Abrams. Whether it’s Snoke’s backstory, the state of the Resistance, or Rey’s parentage, Johnson has shifted the trilogy in a new direction.

Abrams must now retaliate. With the news that he will be directing episode nine, we’re bracing for a host of plot points that will undo Johnson’s work and restore a galaxy far far away to what Abrams thinks it should be. Some of this is normal when there’s a change in directors,* but this time it’s clearly personal. Here’s what you can expect in episode IX.

Spoiler Notice: The Last Jedi and The Force Awakens.

1. Chewbacca Is the Chosen One

Chewie hiding from Storm Troopers on Starkiller Base

In The Force Awakens (TFA), Chewie was a better character than he’s ever been before. He had thoughts and opinions. He came up with better plans than Han. He’s even the first to express his grief when Han dies.* In The Last Jedi (TLJ), his role is, shall we say, lessened.

In this new film, Chewbacca’s accomplishments are restricted to kicking down a door, getting guilt tripped about eating porgs, and shooting some TIE-fighters. We can only assume that if Johnson were directing episode IX, Chewie would be further reduced to a handsome fur rug.

But now Abrams is back in charge, and he’s not gonna let the Wookiee languish. To show Johnson what’s what, I predict that Chewie will be the revealed as the true chosen one. He’ll be a Jedi, of course, with a bowcaster that shoots lightsabers, but that’s not enough. Maz, everyone’s second-favorite wisdom dispenser,* will reveal there is an ancient prophecy about how only a Walking Carpet can defeat the Sith and bring balance to the Force.

If Abrams wants to get really extreme, episode IX might even feature subtitles for Chewbacca. GASP!

2. Luke Is the Nicest Force Ghost

Rey and Luke from The Last Jedi

Except for the brief sidequest to destroy Starkiller Base,* The Force Awakens is all about finding Luke Skywalker. Specifically, it’s about Rey finding Luke so she can learn from him. The film even ends with Rey holding out Luke’s old lightsaber,* waiting for a response.

Two years later and Luke’s reply is to be a real jerk. He casually tosses the lightsaber off a cliff, as if to mock the expectations built up from TFA. Not only does he refuse to train Rey,* but he’s not even interested in stopping the First Order. We find out he’s known about Snoke for years, yet he’s done nothing. For better or worse, this is a far cry from the Luke we knew in the original trilogy.

When Luke finally gets off his butt to help the Resistance, the effort literally kills him. This would seem to make it impossible for Abrams to make further alterations to Luke’s character, but that’s what Force ghosts are for. I predict that episode IX will begin with a transparent Luke appearing to Rey and saying how sorry he is. Then he’ll lead her on the wonderous training montage we all expected. It should only take half the movie.

In addition to training Rey, Ghost-Luke will be very encouraging to the other characters, take back his badmouthing of the Jedi, and talk about how cool and heroic the Resistance was when they were fighting Starkiller Base. And since Force ghosts can affect reality now (unless Yoda was just pretending to bring down lighting on that tree), Luke will probably have a duel with Snoke too. What’s that, you thought Snoke was dead? Well…

3. Snoke Is Two Siths in a Trenchcoat

Snoke from The Force Awakens

Supreme Leader Snoke was one of the bigger question marks around TFA. Audiences wondered where he came from and how there could have been a darkside Force master loose in the galaxy so long* without anyone hearing about him. Viewers also had questions about Snoke’s goals and motives. Was he trying to restore the Empire or build something new? And why?

These questions would have been hard to answer considering how little context TFA provided. It’s understandable, if disappointing, that Johnson decided not to try. Less understandable is having Snoke killed off before the film had reached its climax. I’m sure we’re all quaking in our boots now that Kylo is in charge of the First Order instead of the guy who could apparently read minds from halfway across the galaxy.

Of course, Abrams won’t take this lying down, but how can he fix it? Snoke’s death was pretty explicit; he was cut in half and left on the floor! But this is Star Wars, where tiny aliens abound. In episode IX, it will be revealed that Snoke was not a single Sith master, but TWO Sith masters wearing a single robe of gold lame.

Snoke’s glorious return will be marked with a monologue about how Kylo’s lightsaber attack did nothing but force Lower Snoke to let go of Upper Snoke, and the two played dead as part of their evil plan. What that plan is will remain a mystery, but both Snokes will continually hint about it for the entire film.

4. Rey’s Parents Are Everyone

Rey and Leia hugging.

In The Force Awakens, the only question bigger than those around Snoke was that of Rey’s parentage. This wasn’t simply hinted at or left unexplained; Rey’s wondering about her parents was a major plot point. Considering how important family lineage has been in previous Star Wars films, it’s unsurprising that fans have spent considerable energy speculating on the issue. Obvious choices like Luke, Han, and Leia* have been floated, as have more unusual ideas like Obi-Wan Kenobi or Emperor Palpatine. Some fans even thought Rey’s parents might be two characters from the video game Battlefield II.*

Unlike with Snoke, The Last Jedi does actually answer this question, when Kylo Ren tells Rey her parents were junk-dealing nobodies who sold her for booze money. This was a major shock to many, and clearly not what Abrams had intended when he filmed that shot of Rey’s parents leaving in a spaceship for TFA.

Ordinarily, Abrams could simply write dialogue claiming Kylo was lying or misinformed, but there’s a problem. Love it or hate it, Kylo’s revelation casts a shadow over the entire question of Rey’s parentage. It makes obsessing over their identity seem absurd, because what difference could it really make? Even if her parents are still alive, they’re unlikely to make up for abandoning her on Off-Brand Tatooine,* and she doesn’t need famous parents to legitimize her exploits.

In that context, any normal reveal will seem lackluster, even sheepish. Abrams’s only option is to up the ante. It won’t do for one or even both of Rey’s parents to be someone we know. Instead, he’ll have to reveal that Rey was created in a lab with DNA from every main character of the Star Wars original trilogy. That’ll show Johnson for daring to imagine you don’t need famous parents to be important. Maybe Lando can deliver the news; it’s weird we haven’t seen him in the new films yet.

5. Broom Kid Gets Eaten

Temiri Blagg (Broom Kid) from The Last Jedi

The Last Jedi is, to put it mildly, a bit of a downer. Nearly everyone except the main characters is dead, the First Order is ascendant, and Kylo Ren is firmly irredeemable.* It’s hard to see how the Resistance* can possibly come back from such a crushing defeat.

In an effort to lift the mood a little, Johnson ends the film with a scene of some kid Force-pulling a broom to his hand and then playing with a Resistance decoder ring. It’s uplifting, you see, because hope is still alive in the galaxy’s tiny children. I’m sure that will be a substitute for the trained soldiers the Resistance no longer has.

There are even rumors going around that this kid is going to feature heavily in the next Star Wars trilogy. I hope that isn’t true, both because the kid’s name is Blagg and because giving Star Wars back to the white boys would just be sad at this stage, but it doesn’t matter what I think. This kid seems important to Johnson’s vision for Star Wars, and that means Abrams must destroy him utterly.

Abrams has a number of options at his disposal. If he wants to show maximum disdain, he could have Broom Kid* fall into a trash compactor as a comic scene-ender. That could send Johnson the message that his version of Star Wars is literal garbage. But I’m betting Abrams will want to make more of a production of it. I’ll lay good odds that Broom Kid gets eaten by a sarlacc, the sarlacc is eaten by a space slug, the space slug is blown up, and then Kylo Ren slices up the remains with his lightsaber. That’ll demonstrate whose war has the most stars for sure.


The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi both have their pros and cons. Without more distance, it’s hard to say which film will end up being more influential on the Star Wars franchise. One thing is clear though: Abrams and Johnson have very different visions for a galaxy far far away. It’s too bad Abrams only gets one more film to return fire, while Johnson is getting an entire trilogy. If Disney really cared about us, they’d alternate Abrams and Johnson each movie. It would be like watching a Twitter feud played out in multimillion-dollar films. Or maybe they could get a director who isn’t a white dude, but we don’t want to be too extreme here.

(Psst! If you liked my article, check out my magical mystery game.)

Read more about

 

Comments

  1. SunlessNick

    Regarding #2, I liked this take on Luke. As someone with chronic depression, it rang very true to me.

    Regarding #3, I have seen some people theorise that the Snoke in the throne room was a projection like Luke’s. (But speaking of two Sith, I have to admit after The Force Awakens, my biggest wish for Snoke was that he’d turn out to really be that big).

    Regarding #4, I never got why everyone was so obsessed about Rey’s parents. Or rather, I did, but I disagreed. Yes, she starts out waiting for them – but then she’s outright told by the film’s mentor character that her fantasies about them were holding her back, and she should look forward for her belonging – by association the viewers were told that who her parents were was the wrong thing to obsess about.

  2. Cay Reet

    The Chewbacca theory actually makes sense … he’s been around since the prequels, after all. And, yes, I want subtitles for Chewie!

  3. Julia

    Rey’s “parents” could have just been people who had custody of her when she was young. They could have been kidnappers or some other unscrupulous people who had no trouble leaving her behind when it got inconvenient to drag a kid around. Who her biological parents are can still be open to revelation/plot twist in the next movie.

    • SunlessNick

      I really don’t see the point of Rey having a special origin.

      • Cay Reet

        Neither do I, to be honest. There’s no reason why the hero of the new movies can’t be an ‘everyman.’ I like that idea more than her having ties to any of the established bloodlines (be it Skywalker, Kenobi, or Palpatine).

      • Oren Ashkenazi

        This was mostly a satirical piece, but for the record I am also totally on board with Rey’s parents being no one. I think that’s probably better than any other answer we could get. The thing that really irked me about how it’s presented in this movie is that it’s super easy to retcon, so I have no confidence it’ll stick.

  4. Tracy

    I saw this movie a month ago and I’m still irked by #3. I’m actually embarrassed to admit the extent of how angry, confused and disappointed this film made me.

  5. Yora

    I think Last Jedi is the best Star Wars movie since 1983. Which still doesn’t make it a good one. But at least it gets the look right.

    But I actually don’t buy that the massive ditching of stuff from Force Awakens was done against Abrams’ intentions. He was the executive producer for this movie and the writing was being done while Force Awakens was still in production. He knew what Johnson was doing and had every opportunity to coordinate with him on the plans for Episode 9.

    But most importantly, Johnson wrecking Abrams’ setups for Episode 9 would require that Abrams had any kind of plan. This man never has a plan. His career as a creator of intriguing and mysterious stories is based entirely on just throwing a lot of random crap at the screen and saying “Wooo… What could it mean?! So mysterious. Woo….” He thinks that because mystery is more interesting than getting everything fully explained, there doesn’t need to be any sense behind anything.

    I’m quite certain Abrams never had any plans for who Snoke is, how Vader plays into things, who Rey’s parents are, how Rey and Kylo are connnected, why there is a Resistance, why there’s a First Order, and what the point of Finn and Poe is in the movies.

    • Oren Ashkenazi

      I agree that Abrams never makes actual plans. He probably had no idea who Snoke was or who Rey’s parents were. If he did, he could have written them down and then these movies would proceed with some kind of unified vision.

  6. Justin

    LMAO!

    Thanks for bringing some humor to my pain.

  7. Cay Reet

    This video does a good job at explaining what was new in TLJ. And about why it’s good to go in a new direction instead of just doing the same thing again.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w1VeOlIDD9o&t=1102s

    Now all that remains is to sit back and watch the inevitable fallout over the next movie, because no matter what they do, a lot of people are going to be angry.

Leave a Comment

By submitting a comment, you confirm that you have read and agree to our comments policy (updated 9/3/18). We send comment data to outside parties for spam filtering and other services. See our privacy policy for details.